Panelist: Jennifer McFadden (Business Analyst, New Business Models for News Project)
Jean-Francois Mignon & Nancy Wang (Mignon Media)
Mignon Media created a spreadsheet incorporating two new business model for hyperlocal and the sales, support, and technology framework that we believe is necessary to optimize businesses in the ecosystem. The framework is based on a sample division of a metro market of 5 million people into many smaller markets (20k, 35k, and 60k) to reflect the towns and neighborhoods that comprise a large metropolitan market.
They also have non-for-profit organization’s business model and paid-content model, included in its new news organization model, envisioning a new, metro-wide news organization serving a market of five million people that operates on a smaller scale and performs a wide variety of tasks.
As they have presented the core idea and major numbers in the morning section, in the afternoon’s panel, Jennifer and Nancy used most of the time to answer questions. Here is an except from the Q&A section:
No matter it’s the NGO or paid-content model, or general news hyper local organization, the income statement and ad revenue would follow the metro sample organization. For paid content model, even in the best case scenario (based on Mignon Media’s clients), 2% of the website’s unique visitors become subscribers, paying $8.5 monthly subscription fee for half of average at a 50,000 circulation paper. Averagely, only 1% of unique visitors are willing to pay for subscription for general news content with $ 4.25 monthly fee, except a 30% subscriber churn outlook. For finance news organization (Mignon’s client based in Canada), the percentage is higher, but all subscription are paid by financial institutions, not by individuals. The b2b model cannot copy to other kinds of news organizations as majorly corporation paid for the content
However, the acquisition cost for subscriptions equals at $45. In that case, for a sample metro market of 5 million people, subscription only stands as a quarter of the total revenue as advertising contributes for the rest.
One more thing to think about free content vs superscription is a mix of what those sites are charging, we have to keep in mind of the cost for paid-content loyalty, which means more cost to maintain the loyalty of subscribers, but also they paid more serious attention to the content, and even to the web commercials.